Also on Tuesday at 12:36:
Mona summary: You stated “I would imagine Mona has to be smart to attend a private school. Like I explained earlier in chapter 1, she has the brains but not the money.” I think this all makes good sense. But that means she’s not really “just like everyone else”. Instead she’s “normal” and like all of us “normal” people there are things that make her unique. J In Mona’s case, she’s smart. How will this impact how she reacts to what’s happening around her?
You asked me to imagine how I would react if I was thirsty and suddenly a glass of water appeared in my hand. Good question. Could I explain it away? Am I in a crowd where I can wonder if I somehow got a glass that someone else was carrying as they brushed past me? I bump in to a guy in the crowd. His water spills on my hand. He walks away. I look down to wipe the water off my hand and that’s when I notice I’m actually holding a glass of water. Weird but potentially explainable. I’m sitting in bed thinking about how much I want a glass of water but it’s freezing out and I don’t want to have to get out from under the covers and as I’m debating what to do … the glass of water materializes in my hand. Several things would happen. 1 … I would jump with a start and spill the glass of water all over my nice (dry and warm) bed. 2…I would wonder if I was still asleep & it was all a dream. (please-oh-please-oh-please because then I’m not crazy and my bed is still warm & dry) 3…Once I knew it wasn’t a dream, I would worry that I was going crazy. I mean – who can you possibly tell something like this too? You will be in a psych ward faster than you can say “H-two-O”.
Since you asked about the existing chapters that you’ve written … here it goes.
I thought Chapter “Uh…dunno” was great at laying a foundation for what is to come. Well written & believable. Ways to expand the chapter … What about the research librarian? Is she someone Mona knows – someone who always works the library or is she a stranger? If she’s someone Mona knows, is the snotty little reminder about returning the book justified (Mona is always late returning research books) or is it something unusual? If she’s a stranger, where’s the “normal” librarian? (Or is she simply a stranger because Mona has never used the research area before). Maybe there’s a sign that reminds users that all research materials must be returned 15 minutes before closing and snotty librarian just points to the sign. –or- if you didn’t mean for the librarian to come across as snotty you can have her be more apologetic in her approach. She points to the sign and says “Sorry but it’s library policy. Even on a Friday night. I know there isn’t much time left tonight but you can reserve the book for tomorrow morning if you need it for longer. We open at XX:XX.”
Chapter 1 versus Chapter 2. First, let me say that I love how you tied the “Greek Mythology” class in to both chapters. Very clever. However, I have a little trouble with how she came to be at Haverford. Don’t think about specifics here … I’m really writing about how I felt after reading chapter 1 and then reading chapter 2. Chapter 1 it’s all about where her family wants her to go versus what they can afford versus where she gets accepted. All believable and very real life. Chapter 2 is all about the friendship with Kate and how Kate was going to Haverford and the nerves of waiting for Mona’s acceptance. Also believable. But the 2 don’t really tie together. I think it’s just a minor issue – but after reading both chapters, it left me a little bothered. Sort of like if a friend is telling a white lie … I can’t say what’s wrong but I know something just feels off. That how I felt after reading the 2 chapters back-to-back. Maybe you could say how she (Mona) was really disappointed that she couldn’t go to Haverford when Kate decided to go there. Then you can mention how Kate thought about going to a state school just to be with Mona but her parents wouldn’t let her (maybe Kate’s mom went to Haverford?) and what a blessing it was when Mona got the money that allowed her to go to Haverford too. You can keep both ideas that way.
========================================
On Tuesday, 11 May, from Anne:
Oh so many ideas filtering through my little pea brain. :)
Within myself....the battle is usually NOT with another person, but within myself. What keeps me from greatness, I feel, is many things. Lack of focus much of the time. Being easily distracted, by TV, by movies, books, music. Even being distracted by completely wholesome things. That is where Mona will fight her battles. Within herself. Now....how to bring that OUT in the book and how that will be described - I HAVE NO IDEA. All I know is that this is the way I want to go.
I get that. I think you have to pick ever growing internal conflicts with external factors. The first "battle" if you will is with her own ability to focus, center herself, etc. She's curious where all of this will get her but "is it really worth it?" You know, the allure of doing nothing. A procrastinator's eternal struggle. :)
Once she gets beyond that, her next internal battle can be one of worthiness & commitment. She doubts if she deserves this power. She isn't sure if she is good enough ... literally in the "good versus evil" sense of good. In her mind she wonders if she's too flawed to do this.
Final conflict ... this is the big moral dilemma. Temptation to use the power for non "good" uses. i.e. converting water into gas just because she ran out of gas but has bottled water in the trunk. It's not specifically "evil" in itself - but it also doesn't really serve the greater good. And it becomes the slippery slope. Little things at first that become bigger & bigger. Where do you draw the line? And are there cosmic consequences for wasting the power on non-essential things? I'm thinking that you can go either way. I mean some things in life are never wasted (kindness, love). But some things are ... worship to the wrong things or for the wrong reasons. (i.e. worship is great - unless it's the mighty dollar you worship. Then it's probably wasted worship.) I guess what I'm really asking here is do motivations matter? From what you have said so far, I think you want them to. If that's the case, then there has to be consequences. I don't think that you can have someone receive an external power (yes I get that it comes from internal meditation etc. but it ultimately influences the external world) and not have some external consequences. Those things we do only in our own mind may not significantly impact anyone else ... however, once it leaves our mind and manifests itself in to action (even if it's just talking) now also influences those around us and there are consequences for those actions. It's just that simple. I think for your story to be believable she must be held accountable for her actions and I think that whatever is controlling this power (the force, God, fate, karma, physics, etc) has to have rules that outline those consequences.
Here's the thing with good & evil (even internal battles) ... I don't think it's always cut & dried. For example, good people can do evil things for what they think are good reasons. And evil people can do good things for all the wrong reasons. You have to decide if it's the actions that matter or the motivations. Or a combination of the 2. I know what I want to say but not really how to explain it. Just bear with me here and see if this example helps. I once had a male friend tell me that he believed that the devil was using me to tempt him to sin. Not because I was trying to tempt him to sin but because I was in fact all of the good, generous, noble things that he had been missing from his life. He had a wife & I had a husband and anything other than friendship was out of the question but he found himself spending a lot of time thinking about just how much he would like to ... not do the right thing. Good & evil are not always clearly defined. I certainly don't think I was evil. But I also understood where he was coming from and I understood why he felt the only solution was to break off our friendship. Just something to think about.
============== OLDER IDEAS =========================
Ideas from my new friend Anne that I wanted to capture in this blog:
I've been thinking about this since yesterday morning. I have a couple of questions re: the power.
Can you turn anything in to something else or are there limits? For example, can you turn cancer cells in to healthy cells? What if it requires skill/talent? Can you turn a paint-by-number in to a Piccasso? Plastic lawn furniture into antiques? What about if it requires life? Can you turn a stuffed teddy bear in to a real bear? I'm thinking there are different kinds of "matter" (for lack of a better word). Raw materials (such as sand & crude oil); Processed materials (gasoline, a gold bar, cut & polished diamond); Animate materials (plant life, animals, cells); Crafted Materials (furniture, art). Maybe you want to have certain "physics" apply to what you can create and how you can jump categories.
=============
I love your idea. The moral implications of that kind of power are incredible. Also - it give the whole Jesus turning water in to wine thing a different twist. The fact taht she won't know what's going on at first means that you can also have a lot of fun with things just ... well becoming something different with no explainable reason (other than "I must be going crazy"). I really love it.
============
Are you sure you don't mind me throwing out ideas for your book? I hope you mean it because this has been banging around in my brain for days. What if the "power" was the ability to transport through time (and location). I mean ... it's not time AND space. It's time-space. All inter-related. So it seems logical to me that with the proper "channeling" (is that a word?) you could move through time & space. We have day-to-day proof of observing the past every day. It takes 7 minutes for the light from the sun to reach us - so we see the sun as it was 7 minutes ago. If it blew up right now, it would b 7 minutes before we knew it. And assuming the explosion was also traveling at the speed of light we would see the explosion & be blown to bits simultaneously. Anyway ... I think it would be a cool power. :) Also ... if you were ever thinking of having a series of books, then your "conflict to resolve" could be whatever time-space she ends up in. And you could keep writing new adventures forever. Did you ever see a TV show called "Sliders"? This power would be kind of like that. Book one could be that (a) she has no control over the power (and gets in to some sticky situations as a result) ... (b) she has the moral dilema (if you could go back and kill Hitler, would you? Should you?) ooo and morla dilema #2 which is what if you change history? then (c) using the power has a physical price that has to be paid.
=================
I've been thinking about your story all week. I still haven't read every entry ... I think it's a really great premise for a story. I have some ideas for you re: the powers. I agree that you don't have to have a true "villan" ... instead your conflict could actually come from both moral and physical issues. i.e. using the powers has a physical cost.
Thanks, Anne, and we'll see about how this fits into the book!!